from -
http://www.news.com.au/couriermail/story/0,23739,26358310-952,00.html
Asylum seeker shootings bring out worst in readers
November 17, 2009 12:00am
MONEY, guns and misery, and the ugly face of Australian bigotry, are the stench of the week. Again.
It's very rare here that we discuss the same topic two weeks running, but some of the poisonous bile that has spewed forth in recent days on The Courier-Mail website (most of it cravenly anonymous) cannot be left unreported.
As a proud second-generation Australian (and the son of a World War II refugee), I am ashamed at some of the hatred and insularity displayed by those applauding the decision by Indonesian authorities to open fire on a boatload of Afghan refugees.
In fact, I am embarrassed to call you fellow Australians.
So much for a "fair go" and values of an allegedly Christian society.
Those of you who believe the world's dispossessed and oppressed deserve to be met with a barrage of gunfire while seeking to escape persecution and hardship are more deserving of deportation to some god-forsaken detention camp than the asylum seekers themselves.
Go and live in a country like Burma or Zimbabwe, where the incumbent regimes probably more accurately reflect your core personal values when it comes to compassion, freedom, tolerance and opportunity.
Some respondents to last week's column accused me of being unfair and emotive by bringing the issue of race and racism into the asylum-seeker debate. I don't resile from that and, after reading many of the online opinions on this latest incident, I only regret not writing a piece that was even less restrained.
For those of you who still doubt that Australia harbours a rancid underbelly of bigotry and ignorance, then just read some of the following venom (edited only for spelling, some punctuation and typographical errors):
From Ron of Albany Creek: "Well done Indonesia! Keep up the good work! These illegal immigrants should not make it to Australia. Stuff the do-gooders. Send them out in a boat to meet them in Indonesian waters. End of problem."
Or: "This is brilliant, this is how we should deal with them," posted by David of Buderim, who probably sports stickers like "I shoot and I vote" on the back of his car.
Then Howard Moon ramps it up a little: "If they'd been hit by a wave we'd be raising money for their families. Instead, let's get rid of everyone who has ever come here by boat and their descendants, too."
Memo to Howard: That would mean getting rid of basically everyone from the First Fleet onwards, you goose.
Ian Holthouse of Woombye says: "It is not our problem. It is about time Indonesia did its job, and stopped them coming through their country. No pity should be wasted on illegal migrants. It is overdue using force against this plague."
Ian, you forget these people are human beings, many of whom have suffered deprivations beyond the imagination of most of us. The plague is the regime they are fleeing, not the human beings themselves.
KT reckons: "I don't find anything 'regrettable' about this, they tried to escape and they got shot. A good lesson."
KT, the facts surrounding this incident are still pretty murky, but on your logic I presume then that you would support Queensland police pumping a couple of high-velocity slugs into your children if they resisted arrest? Problem solved, mate? A good lesson, perhaps?
And the gold medal goes to Rod, who said on Sunday afternoon: "I'm racist. I don't want foreigners coming here. I have no sympathy for them. Send them home. (Now hands up anyone else who feels the same but doesn't wish to speak up in fear of upsetting the bleeding-heart brigade)."
And the hands went up. "Rod, I'm racist too. I hate them coming here – get lost I say," was the contribution to reasoned and intelligent debate from one RACINGDUDE of Gold Coast.
In the midst of all this xenophobic effluent from people who make Pauline Hanson look like an intellectual giant, there was also much heated debate surrounding the legacy of Australian servicemen in various conflicts, and what they fought for.
So what did they fight and die for, and what was their legacy?
They fought to rid the world of tyranny and oppression. They fought in World War II against a Nazi Germany that tortured and gassed those who were different from the Aryan ideal, be they Jews, Gypsies, persons of different skin colour or those with disability.
They fought and died bravely in Korea and Vietnam against the perceived threat of communism in the context of a worldwide Cold War that conducted its bloody skirmishes by proxy.
Today, Australia's armed forces fight in lands such as Afghanistan, where our troops are embroiled in a battle against religious fundamentalism and intolerance that breeds terrorism and cruelty.
They are standing up for, and always have stood up for, freedom and a fair go, and in the process have built an enduring legacy of egalitarianism and the Aussie belief in giving a people a chance, and lending a generous hand to those truly in need.
Our troops are fighting against exactly the sort of prejudice and narrow-minded brutality evident among so many of those who support using live ammunition to deal with asylum seekers.
These are desperate people, who – if their plight is assessed as genuine – should be welcomed as a part of the great Australian dream, like countless generations of immigrants (official and otherwise) before them.
To turn our backs, to extend odium and resentment, and to support the use of potentially deadly force, lessens us as a people. It brings us closer to the brutality and cruelty of the homelands that these people are fleeing.
We are the lucky country. Let us not diminish ourselves by becoming ugly Australians.





















